Can it Balance Community and Cash?

What is an IPO?

An IPO, or an Initial Public Offering, is the first sale of a private company’s stock to the public on a stock exchange. Going public is a significant milestone for any company, marking its transition from a private to a public entity. It can provide the necessary capital for expansion, increase the company’s public profile, and provide a liquidity event for investors and employees. This intricate process, however, transcends mere fundraising; it is a strategic odyssey fraught with both the excitement of growth opportunity and the daunting prospect of heightened public and regulatory scrutiny.

The IPO Market in 2024: Slowdown or Springboard?

Conventional economic theory suggests that after COVID-19, IPOs and other transactions, services should have soared off of increased consumer sentiment and market efficiency. However, the opposite happened, according to EY “global IPO volumes were down 8% and proceeds were down 33% compared to 2022” showing that global transactions had taken a downward spiral. Perhaps fueled by companies such as Waystar delaying their IPO until 2024, or the disaster of the IPO from online gaming organisation FaZe (that’s a story for another day). However, the future appears promising, with platforms such as Discord and Shein soon to go public, indicating the potential for greater deal flow in the months to come.

Why Go Public? The Allure of Capital as a Catalyst for Strategic Transformation

At the heart of any IPO lies the potential for greater capital infusion. By offering shares to a vast pool of investors, companies provide themselves with access to a wellspring of funds to propel future growth; whether that be to solidify market share, fund R&D, shed existing debt burdens and attract greater talent, the possibilities are endless.

Why Go Public? The Allure of Capital as a Catalyst for Strategic Transformation

The proceeds from an IPO can be strategically allocated for M&A activity. This allows companies to potentially acquire smaller players within their niche, bolstering their market share and strengthening competitive positioning. A classic example is Facebook’s (now Meta) acquisition after raising $16bn from its 2012 IPO. This influx of capital allowed them to purchase a lesser-known photo-sharing app for a staggering $1bn. That platform was Instagram.

Fuelling Innovation Through Investment

IPO capital can provide the impetus for massive levels of investment in a company’s R&D. The greater levels of public scrutiny force company managers to operate with the strategic imperative of maximising shareholder value through constant innovation. This allows companies to stay ahead of the curve, disrupt their industries and drive cultures of continuous development.

Debt Liberation: Shedding the Burden

Many companies, particularly those in high-growth industries, may carry significant debt burdens carried over from their private operations. Successful IPOs can provide the necessary capital to pay off significant debt burdens, allowing for greater strategic flexibility and more potent investment in growth initiatives.

Talent Acquisition: Attracting the Best and Brightest

A successful, well-published IPO, will enhance a company’s reputation and brand image. This newfound prestige can be leveraged to attract top industry talent, especially when backed by competitive compensation packages and stock options.

The IPO Labyrinth: A Complex Journey

The complexities of the IPO process require the expertise of seasoned investment banks to navigate the patchwork of regulations and requirements of investors, stock exchanges and regulatory bodies.

Unveiling the Company Narrative: Selling a Story

The delivery of a prospectus serves as the cornerstone for any IPO. This document will provide an outline of the company’s health, its business model and its future prospects. It plays a pivotal role in securing investor trust, often navigating a tightrope of stringent financial transparency with strategic ambiguity.

The Roadshow: Garnering Interest

A roadshow is a series of presentations leading up to the IPO. It’s a sales pitch made by the underwriting firm and company management to potential investors. A successful IPO is often predicated upon a successful roadshow. By travelling to major financial hubs, the IPO is introduced to institutional investors, analysts, fund managers, and hedge funds to garner interest in the security.

Regulatory Hurdles: An Endless Web of Compliance

Companies must comply with the requirements of the relevant stock exchange (e.g., ASX, NYSE, NASDAQ) as well as regulatory bodies like the Securities and Exchange Commission in the US (SEC) or ASIC in Australia. This necessitates a lengthy process of the meticulous preparation of legal documents, adherence to accounting standards (e.g. GAAP), and a deep understanding of ever-evolving regulations.

The Duality of an IPO: A Debut with Public Scrutiny

An IPO, though a significant milestone for any company, is a double-edged sword. While it unlocks the myriad of opportunities discussed prior, it also ushers in relentless public scrutiny and heightened accountability.

The Scrutiny Paradox: A Blessing for Transparency, A Burden for Innovation

In the public eye, companies become beholden to a vast and diverse shareholder base with a constant and unrelenting appetite for strong financial performance. Indeed, this environment forces companies to be ruthlessly transparent through constant reporting and regular shareholder meetings. However, it can also lead to relentless short-termism on behalf of management that may overshadow long-term strategic investments. Companies may also find themselves bogged down in bureaucratic processes to ensure compliance with the complex set of regulations public entities are beholden to, potentially stifling agility and the ability of management to take calculated risks.

---

Reddit: A Case Study

The recent IPO of internet giant Reddit serves as a fascinating case study in navigating this paradox. The self-proclaimed “front page of the internet”, Reddit provides a vast network of communities based on people’s interests, where users can dive into their hobbies and interests. Founded in 2005 by Steve Huffman and Alexis Ohanian, two college roommates. Reddit operates as a structured collection of “subreddits,” each dedicated to a point of conversation, topic or theme. Historic funding rounds for the company include $500 million in 2004, $200 million in 2017, $300 million in 2019, and $700 million in 2021.

In 2011, the company became an independent subsidiary of Advance Publications, the parent company of the global mass media company Condé Nast. With a monthly global active user base of 500 million, Reddit is the first social media company to go public since Pinterest in 2019. The IPO for the company was first priced at $34 (USD) a share, placing its market value at $6.4bn under the ticker symbol “RDDT”. RDDT’s stock price skyrocketed 48% on its first day of trading on the 21st of March, opening at $47 and closing at $50.44, giving the company a market cap of $9.5bn.

Reddit has grown to be one of the most visited websites in the world with millions of users and billions of monthly page reviews. The company, however, has faced various challenges and controversies particularly related to content moderation, community management and monetization.

How Reddit runs as the front page of the internet:

Reddit’s structure is hierarchical, with various levels of moderators overseeing different aspects of the platform:

• Executive Leadership: At the top level of the company, Reddit is run by its C-suite executives and upper management, responsible for setting the overall direction and strategy of Reddit as a company, focusing on growth opportunities for the company and aiming for stability and growth.
• Admins/Employees: They are the employees of Reddit who work on site-wide features, policies and community management. They have the highest level of authority and can enforce site-wide rules.
• Subreddit Moderators: Each subreddit has its team of moderators who are responsible for enforcing the rules of the community, managing content and engaging with users. They have the authority to remove posts, ban users and set community guidelines.
• Community members: They are the users who create content, comment and vote on posts. They play a crucial role in shaping the content and discussion on Reddit.

Overall Reddit operates as a decentralised platform, where users have a significant amount of control over the content and discussions within their respective communities, while the company’s leadership oversees the broader vision and operations of the platform.

A Community-Driven Colossus: Reconciling Investor Sentiment with the Interests of Redditors

Reddit’s strength is its vibrant and highly engaged community of “Redditors”. You only need to look toward the phenomenon that was r/WallStreetBets to understand the strength of this online community. Indeed, unlike its more curated counterparts, Reddit thrives on networks like these to foster a fiercely independent – and often rebellious – spirit amongst its users. This is a massive strength for Reddit, however, in the context of now being a public company, this presents significant challenges for its management.

Reddit’s existing culture of free and open communication positions them with a strong base to navigate the transparency requirements of the public markets. Upfront and open communication with investors – many of whom are their own users – regarding future plans will foster trust and engender confidence. However, this heightened scrutiny dually presents a potential clash with the Company’s core value of fostering a free open communication platform. Striking a balance between investor transparency and protecting user privacy, while protecting the autonomy of its existing online communities, will be a delicate tightrope to walk for Reddit’s leadership.

Monetisation and Innovation: A Balancing Act

Many commentators acknowledge that the future success of Reddit is predicated on its ability to monetise its platform. For reference, Reddit as of 2024 is the third most visited site on the internet behind the domains google.com and youtube.com. Yet, staggeringly, only reported revenue of $804m for a net loss of $90.8m in 2023.

So what gives?

Unlike its social media counterparts that rely heavily on advertising revenue, Reddit has remained steadfast in its commitment to a user-first M.O. Reddit has traditionally had a limited Ad load. While some banner ads exist, they are by design unobtrusive and often tailored to the niches of specific subreddits. This approach, while lauded by Redditors, translates to significantly smaller revenues compared to other ad-driven social media platforms. Take Facebook, which despite having a lower visitor count than Reddit in 2023, generated $131.95bn in ad revenue alone. The platform does offer a premium membership tier, which provides users with ad-free browsing, access to exclusive content within certain subreddits, and additional customisation options. While this subscription model is gaining traction, it is currently not in a position to be the sole driver of revenues.

A Promising Start: Reddit’s Q1 Earnings

If last week’s quarterly earnings are any indicator, Reddit is on the right track. Reddit’s revenue climbed 48% from $163.7 million a year earlier, reporting $222.7 million in ad revenue for the quarter, up 39% YoY, largely outperforming analyst’s projections, causing shares to soar 17% to $58 in after-hours trading. This growth, however, may only be the tip of the iceberg. Reddit CEO Steve Huffman emphasised on the company’s earnings call that its “still early in its monetization journey” through its data licensing business, despite seeing over 500% growth in revenue for the same period last year. Huffman also suggested that the platform could see outsized benefits from the emergence of AI-generated content and the translation of its content to languages other than English through LLMs (Large Language Models) to do “translation at human level quality” and “help accelerate international transfer.” However, the need to balance financial success with the community values of the platform remains. While impressive user and revenue growth suggests Reddit’s core identity is yet to be compromised, long-term questions persist about Reddit’s ability to navigate this balancing act between solid financial performance and the reaction from its vocal and sceptical community regarding its monetization methods.

The Risk of “Going Dark”: Preventing a User Mutiny

In a bid to win over these sceptics, Reddit set aside reportedly 8% of the total IPO shares for its most active users, likely its cohort of moderators. This gesture was touted as a “thank you” to the “Redditors who have contributed to making Reddit what it is today.” However, the underlying tension within Reddit’s community has remained fervent. As mentioned, the key component of the platform’s unique community-centric identity lies within its forum-based structure, each governed by a cadre of powerful, though unpaid, volunteer moderators. This dynamic sparked a “moderator revolt” last year, causing roughly one-third of all subreddits to “go dark” for two days across June.

The catalyst for this self-inflicted cannibalisation was an innocuous one: the monetisation of Reddit’s application programming interface (API). Previously free, access to this API fueled third-party applications used by moderators for the efficient management of subreddits. This sudden monetisation of a platform function fueled rumours platform-wide that in pursuit of its IPO, Reddit was prioritising revenue generation over the needs of its volunteer workforce and, by extension, the user experience.

The moderator revolt may provide some indicia of what is to come. Moderators, largely viewed as integral to the platform’s success, may suddenly feel their contributions are being devalued – mere unpaid labour in the eyes of a company focused on meeting its financial future and the interests of its shareholders.

At a Crossroads: The Future of Reddit

Clearly, Reddit’s IPO marks a pivotal moment, a metaphorical Rubicon the company has chosen to cross. As Reddit seeks to navigate uncharted territory as a publicly traded company, it is uncertain what direction the company will take: a step too far along the road of monetisation, and internal mutiny may bring the company to a standstill yet again, a step too little, and they will face the financial consequences. Only time will tell if management can successfully walk the tightrope of being a community-driven publicly traded company. The company’s future hinges on its ability to foster a sense of trust with both its investors and its unique loyal user base, ensuring a new era of prosperity, not the erosion of the very elements that make the platform the unique bastion of conversation it is today.